None: Singular or Plural?

by

I might have addressed “none” before, but this example strikes me as a good illustration of the effect of context.

After all, none is a contraction of “not (even) one.” That’s a singular, right? But the context of the word often says none of [a group of something], and we grab that plural object of “of” to signal the number of “none.” Technically, this is incorrect. We get the number of a verb from its subject, not from some modifying phrase. This is easier to say if you take out that prepositional phrase: “None is how many cookies you get before supper.”

Well, how about this example? Last panel:

https://www.gocomics.com/brewsterrockit/2021/08/11

Singular doesn’t feel right, does it? If she had said “not one,” the singular feels better…

You may also like

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. Accept Read More